Julio VOLTARELLI
Bone Marrow Stem Cells vs Diabetes
https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn11571-rebuilt-immune-system-shakes-off-diabetes/
10 April 2007
'Rebuilt'
immune system shakes off diabetes
By
Roxanne Khamsi
Diabetics appear to have been cured with a one-off treatment
that rebuilds their immune system, according to a new study.
The technique, which uses patients’ own bone marrow cells, has
freed 14 of 15 patients with type 1 diabetes from their
dependence on insulin medication.
So far, participants in the trial have gone 18 months without
insulin therapy following the procedure, on average. One patient
has lasted three years without needing such injections.
In patients with type 1 diabetes, which typically strikes in
early childhood or adolescence, the immune system appears to
erroneously attack cells in the pancreas that produce the
hormone insulin. Without insulin, blood sugar levels in the body
spiral out of control. People with diabetes receive insulin
therapy, often in the form of self-injected shots, to keep their
blood sugar levels under control.
Wipe out
Scientists have speculated that “resetting” the immune system
might stop it from attacking the insulin-producing cells in the
pancreas.
Julio Voltarelli, at the University of Sao Paulo in Brazil, and
colleagues recruited 15 people aged 14 to 31 years who had
recently been diagnosed with type 1 diabetes. Roughly 60% to 80%
of these patients’ insulin-producing cells had been destroyed by
the time of their diagnosis, and all needed regular insulin
shots.
The researchers removed bone marrow stem cells from the
patients, who were then given drugs such as cytotoxan to wipe
out their immune cells. Without an immune system, the patients
were vulnerable to infection and so they were given antibiotics
and kept in an isolation ward. They participants did not undergo
radiation treatment – as leukaemia patients often do as part of
a bone marrow transplant – and so had fewer side effects and
less risk of organ damage.
Two weeks later, the patients received infusions of their own
stem cells into their bloodstream via the jugular vein, which
re-established their immune systems.
Throughout this time and following the stem cell transplant, the
research team continued taking blood samples to assess how much
insulin each patient required.
Free for
life?
Of the 15 patients, 12 no longer needed insulin shots within a
few days of undergoing the procedure. One patient from the group
had a relapse and needed to take insulin for one year, before
becoming insulin-independent again – and has remained this way
for 5 months.
Of the remaining two participants, one stopped needing insulin
shots for one year after the transplant but has spent the past
two months back on the shots, and the final participant’s
diabetes did not respond to the stem cell treatment.
Those who responded to the treatment have not needed insulin
shots – so far, for an average 18 months – and had not relapsed
at the time of study publication. One patient had gone as long
as 35 months without needing insulin therapy. “It may be that
they become insulin-free for life. We don’t know,” says
Voltarelli.
Exactly why some patients responded to the treatment and one did
not remains a mystery. “It could be due to differences in
genetic background or severity of the immune attack,” Voltarelli
suggests.
During the course of the trial, one patient developed pneumonia
as a result of the immune-suppressing drugs used in the
procedure. Two others developed complications, including thyroid
dysfunction and early menopause, but it is not clear if these
relate to the stem cell transplant
Honeymoon
period
Jay Skyler, who heads the Diabetes Research Institute at the
University of Miami in Florida, US, cautions that the trial did
not include a control group. Skyler adds some people experience
a remission of symptoms shortly after being diagnosed with type
1 diabetes, and the increase in insulin production seen among
study participants might be related to this “honeymoon period”.
Skyler also notes it is unclear exactly how the insulin
production in the patients increased.
Still, he says that the trial has “shown some potentially
promising results”. And Voltarelli is hopeful that this type of
approach could help patients with type 1 diabetes avoid some of
the long-term complications that arise from the illness, such as
kidney, eye and nerve damage, which result from chronically high
levels of blood sugar.
Journal
reference: Journal of the American Medical Association (vol
297, p 1568)
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(13)60750-3/fulltextJulio
Voltarelli
March 30, 2013
DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(13)60750-3
Julio
Voltarelli

Leading expert in stem cell transplantation for the treatment of
autoimmune diseases. Born on Dec 17, 1948, in Fernandópolis,
Brazil, he died of complications of a liver transplant on March
21, 2012, in Blumenau, Brazil, aged 63 years.
Julio Voltarelli's passion and vision was to be able to modify
the immune system in order to change a disease's course. As the
coordinator of the Bone Marrow Transplant Unit at the Ribeirão
Preto School of Medicine at the University of São Paulo in
Brazil, Voltarelli was one of the first researchers in the world
to use haemopoietic stem cells found in bone marrow to treat
autoimmune diseases. “Julio was a pioneer driven by an internal
compass, directed by uncanny intuition, steadied by intellect,
and grounded by sincerity and honesty to improve this world
through restoring to people what disease had extinguished”, says
Richard Burt, associate professor and Chief of the Division of
Medicine-Immunotherapy for Autoimmune Diseases at Northwestern
University Feinberg School of Medicine in Chicago, USA. Since
2001, Voltarelli's team has undertaken almost 200 stem cell
transplantations for autoimmune diseases, including type 1
diabetes, multiple sclerosis, systemic sclerosis, and lupus.
Working with Burt, Voltarelli developed a protocol for
transplanting stem cells in patients with type 1 diabetes. The
researchers first removed cells from the bone marrow of patients
and then treated the patients with radiation to destroy their
immune systems, which were attacking the pancreatic ß cells
responsible for producing insulin. Patients' stem cells were
then injected back into their bone marrow in the hope of
repopulating the pancreas with functioning ß cells. Voltarelli
and his colleagues reported that 20 out of 23 patients who
received the treatment no longer needed to inject insulin to
control their blood sugar levels; for some, the treatment was
effective for up to 3 years. It was, the researchers wrote in
the Journal of the American Medical Association in 2009, “the
only treatment capable of reversing type 1 DM [diabetes
mellitus] in humans” at that time.
Voltarelli encountered doubt and resistance from colleagues who
questioned why diabetes should be treated with a high-risk
transplantation procedure, according to Maria Carolina Oliveira,
a staff physician in the Department of Internal Medicine at the
Ribeirão Preto School of Medicine, who worked closely with
Voltarelli. But the improvement in patients' quality of life
with treatment and the possibility that chronic complications,
such as eye and kidney disease, would diminish as a result
validated Voltarelli's efforts. His contribution in Brazil was
important, says Oliveira: “He will definitely be remembered for
his courage and audacity. He started something new in the
country and worked against other people's opinion, especially
concerning the type 1 diabetes stem cell transplantation
protocol.”
Voltarelli graduated from the Ribeirão Preto School of Medicine
at the University of São Paulo in 1972 and completed a residency
in internal medicine and haematology there 2 years later. He
received a doctorate in haematology and clinical immunology from
the same institution in 1981 and then completed postdoctoral
fellowships in the USA at the University of California, San
Francisco, the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in
Seattle, and the Scripps Research Institute in San Diego. In
1992, he returned to Brazil and established the Bone Marrow
Transplant Unit at the Ribeirão Preto School of Medicine.
Over the course of his career, Voltarelli published more than
130 articles and edited the first book in Portuguese on stem
cell transplantation and clinical immunology; he was also on the
editorial board of the journal Cell Transplantation. Shortly
before his death, his colleagues elected him President of the
Brazilian Society of Bone Marrow Transplantation. Voltarelli
lobbied for the creation of a national transplant register in
Brazil and for the certification of physicians who perform
transplantations in the country. “He was the most loyal and
correct scientist I ever worked with. He was extremely smart but
extremely modest. He always discussed all of the protocols and
projects with the whole group, taking into account all
opinions”, remembers Belinda Simoes, who worked with Voltarelli
for 20 years and who is the current coordinator of the Bone
Marrow Transplant Unit. Voltarelli is survived by his wife and
two daughters.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3285188/
PLoS One. 2012; 7(2): e31887.
2012 Feb 22.
doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0031887
Acute
Response of Peripheral Blood Cell to Autologous
Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation in Type 1 Diabetic
Patient
Xiaofang
Zhang, Lei Ye, Jiong Hu, Wei Tang, Ruixin Liu, Minglan
Yang, Jie Hong, Weiqing Wang, Guang Ning,
and Weiqiong Gu
Abstract
Objective
Autologous nonmyeloablative hematopoietic stem cell
transplantation (AHST) was the first therapeutic approach that
can improve ß cell function in type 1 diabetic (T1D) patients.
This study was designed to investigate the potential mechanisms
involved.
Design and
methods
We applied AHST to nine T1D patients diagnosed within six
months and analyzed the acute responses in peripheral blood for
lymphocyte subpopulation as well as for genomic expression
profiling at the six-month follow-up.
Results
We found six patients obtained insulin free (IF group) and
three remained insulin dependent (ID group); C-peptide
production was significantly higher in IF group compared to ID
group. The acute responses in lymphocytes at six-month follow-up
include declined CD3+CD4+, CD3+CD8+ T cell population and
recovered B cell, NK cell population in both groups but with no
significant differences between the two groups; most
immune-related genes and pathways were up-regulated in
peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) of both groups while
none of transcription factors for immune regulatory component
were significantly changed; the IF group demonstrated more
AHST-modified genetic events than the ID group and distinct
pattern of top pathways, co-expression network as well as ‘hub’
genes (eg, TCF7 and GZMA) were associated with each group.
Conclusions
AHST could improve the islet function in newly diagnosed T1D
patients and elimination of the islet specific autoreactive T
cells might be one of the mechanisms involved; T1D patients
responded differently to AHST possibly due to the distinct
transcriptional events occurring in PBMC.
Type 1 diabetes (T1DM) is an organ specific autoimmune disease,
resulting from chronic immune attack against pancreatic beta
cells [1]. Although it is thought to be mediated mainly by T
helper 1 cells, a complex interaction of immune cells including
CD4+T cell, CD8+Tcell and innate immune cell NK cell, B cell and
antigen presentation cell is actually involved in the
pathogenesis [2]. This course of immune-destruction is
subclinical until approximately 60% to 80% of the beta-cell mass
is destroyed, when the amount of beta-cell mass is insufficient
to maintain glucose homeostasis and the clinical diagnosis of
T1DM is established [3]. The best-established treatment is to
tightly control the blood glucose by intensive insulin therapy
[4]. However, long-term substitutive insulin therapy is still
associated with major constraints and lack of effectiveness in
preventing chronic vascular and neurological complications.
Immunointervention therapy, which targets the causal pathogenic
mechanism, therefore, may represent the only sensible strategy.
Clinical trial of immunosuppression drugs (cyclosporine),
antigen therapy (GAD) or immunoregulatory agents (anti-CD3
antibody) have obtained efficacy in patients with T1DM, however
obstacles such as adverse effects, lack of long-lasting
improvement and especially the exogenous insulin requirement
remain still as a medical challenging [5].
In 2007, Julio C. Voltarelli's group reported the first clinical
trial using AHST as a potential approach in cases of T1D [6].
Indeed, for the first time these studies demonstrated that AHST
led to prolonged insulin independence coupled with a significant
increase of c-peptide production. A follow-up study published
two years later confirmed the insulin independence was due to
improved ß cell function instead of a prolonged honeymoon [7].
Therefore, AHST has been the only T1D-related management shown
to preserve ß cell function. However, AHST requires a relatively
aggressive immune-intervention and complications such as
pneumonia and endocrine dysfunction have been noted. Therefore,
a need exists to be able to target those patients who will
receive the most benefit from AHST and to further clarify the
mechanisms involved in ß cell function recovery so that the
strategy can be optimized and a broader patient population can
benefit from this treatment approach.
In this study, we applied AHST therapy to a group of nine
patients with newly diagnosed T1D and specifically investigated
their immune reconstitution, as well as performed transcriptome
profiling on their PBMC pre-treatment and six months
post-treatment to identify the acute responsive events, which
might give helpful insights to clarify the therapeutic
mechanisms...
Results
We found six patients obtained insulin free (IF group) and
three remained insulin dependent (ID group); C-peptide
production was significantly higher in IF group compared to ID
group. The acute responses in lymphocytes at six-month follow-up
include declined CD3+CD4+, CD3+CD8+ T cell population and
recovered B cell, NK cell population in both groups but with no
significant differences between the two groups; most
immune-related genes and pathways were up-regulated in
peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) of both groups while
none of transcription factors for immune regulatory component
were significantly changed; the IF group demonstrated more
AHST-modified genetic events than the ID group and distinct
pattern of top pathways, co-expression network as well as ‘hub’
genes (eg, TCF7 and GZMA) were associated with each group.
Conclusions
AHST could improve the islet function in newly diagnosed T1D
patients and elimination of the islet specific autoreactive T
cells might be one of the mechanisms involved; T1D patients
responded differently to AHST possibly due to the distinct
transcriptional events occurring in PBMC.
https://academic.oup.com/edrv/article/32/6/725/2354736
Voltarelli Nicholas Zavazava
Endocrine Reviews, Volume 32, Issue 6, 1 December 2011,
Pages 725–754, https://doi.org/10.1210/er.2011-0008
Immunological
Applications of Stem Cells in Type 1 Diabetes
Paolo
Fiorina Julio Voltarelli Nicholas Zavazava
Current approaches aiming to cure type 1 diabetes (T1D) have
made a negligible number of patients insulin-independent. In
this review, we revisit the role of stem cell (SC)-based
applications in curing T1D. The optimal therapeutic approach for
T1D should ideally preserve the remaining ß-cells, restore
ß-cell function, and protect the replaced insulin-producing
cells from autoimmunity. SCs possess immunological and
regenerative properties that could be harnessed to improve the
treatment of T1D; indeed, SCs may reestablish peripheral
tolerance toward ß-cells through reshaping of the immune
response and inhibition of autoreactive T-cell function.
Furthermore, SC-derived insulin-producing cells are capable of
engrafting and reversing hyperglycemia in mice. Bone marrow
mesenchymal SCs display a hypoimmunogenic phenotype as well as a
broad range of immunomodulatory capabilities, they have been
shown to cure newly diabetic nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice, and
they are currently undergoing evaluation in two clinical trials.
Cord blood SCs have been shown to facilitate the generation of
regulatory T cells, thereby reverting hyperglycemia in NOD mice.
T1D patients treated with cord blood SCs also did not show any
adverse reaction in the absence of major effects on
glycometabolic control. Although hematopoietic SCs rarely revert
hyperglycemia in NOD mice, they exhibit profound
immunomodulatory properties in humans; newly hyperglycemic T1D
patients have been successfully reverted to normoglycemia with
autologous nonmyeloablative hematopoietic SC transplantation.
Finally, embryonic SCs also offer exciting prospects because
they are able to generate glucose-responsive insulin-producing
cells. Easy enthusiasm should be mitigated mainly because of the
potential oncogenicity of SCs.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19835616
Diabetol Metab Syndr. 2009 Oct 16;1(1):19.
doi: 10.1186/1758-5996-1-19.
Stem
cell therapy for type 1 diabetes mellitus: a review of
recent clinical trials.
Couri CE,
Voltarelli JC.
Abstract
Stem cell therapy is one of the most promising treatments
for the near future. It is expected that this kind of therapy
can ameliorate or even reverse some diseases. With regard to
type 1 diabetes, studies analyzing the therapeutic effects of
stem cells in humans began in 2003 in the Hospital das Clínicas
of the Faculty of Medicine of Ribeirão Preto - SP USP, Brazil,
and since then other centers in different countries started to
randomize patients in their clinical trials. Herein we summarize
recent data about beta cell regeneration, different ways of
immune intervention and what is being employed in type 1
diabetic patients with regard to stem cell repertoire to promote
regeneration and/or preservation of beta cell mass.The Diabetes
Control and Complications Trial (DCCT) was a 7-year longitudinal
study that demonstrated the importance of the intensive insulin
therapy when compared to conventional treatment in the
development of chronic complications in patients with type 1
diabetes mellitus (T1DM). This study also demonstrated another
important issue: there is a reverse relationship between
C-peptide levels (endogenous indicator of insulin secretion)
chronic complications - that is, the higher the C-peptide
levels, the lower the incidence of nephropathy, retinopathy and
hypoglycemia. From such data, beta cell preservation has become
an additional target in the management of T1DM 1.